Retired Taxpayers Lose Tax Court Case
By John Alan Cohan, Attorney at Law
The Tax Court held that a married couple who engaged in a cattle and horse breeding activity were not engaged in a business, despite the full-time nature of the venture. The case was Garbini v. Commissioner IRS [T.C. Summary Opinion 2004-7]. Mr. Garbini, of Myrtle Creek, Oregon, listed his occupation as a rancher, and his wife indicated she was a housewife. Both taxpayers were retired during the two taxable years in issue, and for Mr. Garbini this was a full time venture. They had a net loss of $127,341 in one year, and $124,584 for a second year at issue.
The court examined whether the taxpayers carried on the activity with the actual and honest objective of making a profit. Although a reasonable expectation of profit is not required, the facts and circumstances must indicate that the taxpayer entered into the activity, or continued the activity, with the actual and honest objective of making a profit.
The court said that the taxpayers did not seek expert advice before entering the activity, and that was viewed with disfavor. They had no business plan to prove that their activity originated with the honest objective of making a profit.
No single factor is controlling in deciding whether a horse or cattle venture is engaged in for profit. In applying the factors to determine profit objective, the court focused on the manner in which Mr. Garbini carried on the activity. The fact that the taxpayer carries on the activity in a businesslike manner and maintains complete and accurate books and records indicates that the activity is engaged in for profit. In this case, the court said that there was little by way of books and records. Rather, Mr. Garbini made a monthly list of expense categories and, based on his canceled checks, recorded the amounts expended for each category.
At trial, Mr. Garbini submitted various invoices, canceled checks, and the monthly lists for the taxable years in issue. The court said that he did not keep the type of records which could be used to increase the profitability of a business. He never prepared budgets or market projections which would outline strategies for ensuring a profitable business venture. The court said that his recordkeeping practice of creating monthly lists from canceled checks simply was inadequate and not indicative of a prudent and reasonable person in business.
Mr. Garbini said that he made efforts to reduce expenses in order to operate the ranch in a profitable manner. Nothing in the record indicated what efforts he actually made to reduce expenses. Mr. Garbini never ascertained how or when he would make a profit or how he could change his operating methods to improve his profitability. Mr. Garbini worked on the ranch almost every day and employed one full-time ranch hand, who performed general maintenance of the property and barns. Mr. Garbini occasionally hired outside temporary labor.
There were no sales during the years at issue.
One strength in this case that unfortunately was not set forth adequately in the evidence was that according to Mr. Garbini the ranch had increased in value as a result of improvements he had made. Mr. Garbini testified that he bought the property for $566,000 in its undeveloped condition, and its value at the time of trial was $15 million. However, he did not provide any evidence other than his verbal testimony.
In order to prove this, there must be introduced into evidence an expert’s report showing the appreciation in value, but in all the court had was the taxpayer’s testimony.
Mr. Garbini also argued that part of the ranch activity involved planting and harvesting trees. He stated that he had planted 3,000 to 5,000 trees per year, and that they are suitable for harvesting after 7 years. The court noted that no trees were harvested during the taxable years in issue.
The court also considered the history of income or losses with respect to the activity. Mr. Garbini did not provide a history of income or losses for the activity. During the taxable years in issue, losses exceeded $250,000, an average of $ 125,000 for each year. Mr. Garbini claimed that the losses have gradually declined, but this was not adequately presented.
Over a period of about 12 years, the losses were losses over $1,500,000. There was no evidence of any profit year.
The court considered the financial status of the taxpayers. The court noted that as a result of their other income, the taxpayers realized substantial tax benefits from the approximate $125,000 loss deduction for each taxable year in issue.
The court also said that there were elements of personal pleasure or recreation even though they did not ride the horses. The court simply said that the taxpayers probably had personal pleasure from residing on a large ranch.
Taking the record as a whole, the court concluded that the taxpayers did not possess the actual and honest objective of making a profit from their operations. Because they had no gross income for the taxable years in issue, none of their claimed expenses were deductible.
[John Alan Cohan is an attorney who has served the livestock and horse industries since 1981. For consultations, telephone at: (310) 278-0203 or e-mail at johnalancohan@aol, or visit his web site at www.JohnAlanCohan.com.]
Michael Jeffcoat Wins SWRHA WinStar World Casino Limited Non Pro & Non Pro Prime Time on Spooks Gotta Run
With a score of 220.5, Michael Jeffcoat of Waurika, Oklahoma, claimed the SWRHA's Limited Non Pro and Non Pro Prime Time Championships, finished as the Reserve Champion of the Intermediate Non Pro, and tied for fourth in the Non Pro. He was riding Spooks Gotta Run, and won $5,244.
"I thought he did very, very well," said Jeffcoat of the Spooks Gotta Gun stallion, out of Prettywhizprettydoes. "Possum (Spooks Gotta Run) has a huge cheering section, and they were all cheering for him today."
Jeffcoat, who owns former National Reining Horse Association Non Pro Futurity and Derby Champion Jacspin, purchased Possum in September of 2010. "We were looking for a Gunner-bred colt to breed to my Jacspin mares, and we found this guy," he explained. Possum is a full-sibling to the 2010 NRHA Futurity Open Champion Spooks Gotta Whiz. "We found this guy and purchased him from Clint and Liz Haverty."
Jeffcoat plans to show Possum at the NRHA Futurity in the Non Pro, and plans for the stallion to compete with an Open rider at the large Derbies in 2012, including the NRHA Derby and the National Reining Breeders Classic.
"I thank Clint and Liz, as well as Marco Formentin - he's the trainer who has helped me get here this year," he said.
Breeders Spotlights
ROYAL BLUEPRINT
Introducing ROYAL BLUEPRINT a beautiful 2008 black stallion for the 2012 breeding season. Read More
Members Spotlight
MINDY COSTELLO
Mindy, of The 7C Ranch, tells a story of how even a blind squirrel finds a nut now and then. A story of two amazing horses, two great friends and a Select World Show she'll never forget. Read More
Check Out Your 2011 World Champions
See their photos and download all the results on our WRR page (click the heading above)
We Hope Everyone Enjoyed The World Round Up & Review!
You can review and order photos from all three days by going to our official photography sponsor's website at: http://www.swinarskiphotography.com/FQH2011/
Enjoy Showing Horses Again - Show with the FQHR
We expect our horses to be versatile and not specialized. They are allowed to move more naturally than many other groups. FQHR shows offer classes in six categories: show, cow horse, ranch horse, speed, team timed events and conformation which is encouraged to be held after performance classes so it can be judged more on form to function. An exhibitor can ride in a variety of classes at the shows and not risk being bored waiting for a class.
We hope you'll:
Join the FQHR
Register a horse
and Show with an FQHR affiliate near you this season.
